In reply to 4oclockguy.

So, 40clockguy, did Jesus come to seek and save the lost Lutherans? I hope that's not what you intended to say. Last time I checked, Jesus died on the cross for all sinners. Not just the Lutheran ones. LCMS folks are only 0.03% (not 3%--.03%) of the world's population. Christ didn't die for such an exclusive group. He died for all, that some might be saved. I think his batting average is probably better than.0003.

I agree with you that we cannot expect a holy company which is made up of unholy people.

This whole discussion is so insane! The fact is, there is virtually no-where you can spend your money today and be assured that "your dollars" won't be used for things you are opposed to (morally or otherwise) For example: I'll bet most of you shop at Home Depot and they are a HUGE supporter of Gay Pride parades around the country and that would certainly ruffle a lot of Lutheran feathers (though, it would seem, not very many anymore). Another fact is that most of our money has traces of cocaine and other drugs on it so should we stop using cash because its used for sinful activities?

This discussion is starting to sound very much like a Congregational Assembly meeting where everyone is fighting over whether the church secretary should get that 50 cents/hour raise this year. "I have a right to say where my money goes!" Well, I hate to tell you this, but its not your money. Its God's money and all you have been asked to do is be a good steward of what he's given you. You elected council people and called a pastor to take care of the details so that you could be led into service to others and worship to God. Your money isn't the point of your faith.

If you feel that your stewardship is compromised by giving to Thrivent, or your congregation, or wherever, then ask God where he wants you to give it. Just don't pretend to think that you really have any say in where it goes after it leaves your wallet and don't horde it because God has told you "Thou shalt not ..." give to people who disagree with you.